Re: breast stroke
Hallo, Landlady,
Perhaps listening to my experience may help you to make up your mind about breaststroke swimming. Prior to getting the hip replacement I had been a reasonably good breaststroke swimmer, but not up to competitive level. It would take me about 40 minutes to swim a mile. About 7 or 8 years ago, I started to notice that after a swim I couldn't raise my leg onto the changing room bench to deal with shoes and socks. After a few days I was ready to go again and swam hard, with the same result. I didn't know it at the time, but it was my hip starting to go wrong.
So, after my replacement last November, I asked the surgeon whether I could swim or not, and if so what strokes? Breaststroke was a no no. I asked whether I could do a very gentle keep afloat kind of breaststroke if I were in a lake or river and wanted to keep the head up to enjoy the scenery. After some hesitation, he replied that it would be OK but that on no account must I kick out hard with the affected leg. I understood that he was concerned about dislocation, and didn't pursue the matter further. It has since occurred to me that after a time, when the tissues have regrouped round the surgery site I may again be able to swim a fuller breaststroke. But I wouldn't think of swimming fully again until after I have asked him to reconsider, maybe at the one year mark. I would appreciate any comment Josephine might make about this.
In the meantime, I have been trying to teach myself the front crawl, which he said would be fine. Gradually I have worked up to swimming a mile on front crawl, but it took 46 minutes, slower than the previous breaststroke, but then, maybe I haven't regained all the stamina lost after the operation.
So my interpretation is that breaststroke is OK provided that the injured leg goes through the motion without any pressure or hard kicking. Otherwise learn crawl, but I realise it is not an easy stroke to come to later in life.
Above all get in the water and enjoy it. Some people at my gym do nothing more than walk up and down the pool. That's like dry land walking but with much of the weight off the joint. Good exercise but a bit dull if you have nobody to talk to. Perhaps walk with a friend, though simultaneous smoking and chocolate eating are not recommended.
All the best,
Alan