@Mojo333 ..did not want to take attention to Christian's thread by replying to you on his thread, so here I am on yours.....
The weirdest thing happened last Friday.. I mentioned the previous surgeon in another post (the confident cowboy with the excellent reputation who only does the anterior procedure, several hundred annually in fact). I ran into him at the grocery store and he ended up speaking with me for a solid 20 minutes.
I explained to him what my reservations were and he was very amenable to accepting my position about him, etc. As I live on my own with a zero support system, I had really wanted to go with the anterior approach initially. One of things that was really depressing me (hence the beginning of the "Pre-Op Blues" thread) was going to be my lack of independence for 6-8 weeks with the posterior. Also being told that I cannot ride the bus for 3 months was a killer for me as I depend on the bus to get around San Francisco! (Used to have a car, but got rid of it before attending grad school on the UK..plus SF is so small and compact that one does not need a car).
Anyway, Dr. Cowboy ,(okay, this really isn't fair as although the cowboy is very self-confident, he also exceptionally nice without any arrogance whatsoever), promised he could fit me in for surgery in August and he did (8/28).I met with the posterior surgeon today and she thought it was a good idea if I postponed my surgery with her for next Monday until I meet the cowboy again next week. She wanted me to make sure I was comfortable with my decision. She used to do anterior, but has stopped because she learned that the long-term success rate is only 2/3 of patients and the risk f long-term nerve damage is as high as 20%! Mind you, 90% of her patients are well over 65 and are more prone to falls/fracture.
The surgeon that trained her and who she still works with, is still performing the anterior approach and she did emphasize that there have been successful anterior surgeries. I know that you too had the anterior approach for your bilateral.
So conflicted at the moment!