I joined the site 6 months before my tkr. I had just had another meniscus repair and was told I needed I tkr. I had already had 10 knee surgeries and not done PT, so I totally agreed with the gentle BS recovery! But, I didn't know what to expect after a tkr before this site. I read just about every thread involving the recovery, so like SusieShoes, I knew what was normal and what wasn't normal. Thank God, all my aches and pains, swelling and bruising was all normal. To have peace of mind is half the battle of healing! I also follow the daily activity schedule as best as I could. I would recommend the BS way to anyone having a replacement. It's a shame so many won't even listen to us. We just want to help!