Hi bfan, think we're same day or close. I too went on vacation, to the Oregon coast last month (end of my 6th month) and did stupid things like walk at a slant, slide in deep sand (in directions my knee questioned!), run from waves, went to a baseball game with stairs, and walked up to 13000 steps on several days. I iced, tried to elevate, but it got worse and worse and is back to maybe month 3. Have yet to feel glad i did it, very frustrating and depressing beyond the earlier down feelings closer to surgery. I am very encouraged by others' comments, but wanted to just verify to you and others at 7 months two steps back seems the norm. Decided to just go kayaking Tuesday, needed lots of help in and out but did it and feel happy about that! (still hurting, feels like my kneecap is stuck to one side, deep pain laterally, sometimes at rest). Have you actually seen surgeon again? I was considering but im so afraid something will be wrong i cant! I cannot bear the thought of one more knife! I feel so much better reading these tales of hope...but my husband wants me to get checked.