@Laurenkate A lot of people opt for spinal anesthesia for this surgery. My understanding, and if I'm wrong I'm sure someone who knows will come along and correct me, is that most of those are not actually fully awake, but are either in a more drowsy state or out totally with whatever the docs use. I have heard from a few people who say they were fully awake and if that's so, that's their and their doctor's choice, but never will be mine.
As for recovery-I totally agree-those stories of being pain free from day one and back to their "normal" life at a week, are, IMHO, balderdash. I have noticed that many men seem to be the ones saying they're pain free and fine right away and never had a single problem, etc. Not to bash men, but sometimes it seems to me their male egos or something won't allow them to admit, even to themselves, how much pain they had, or are having, and how hard a time they really had, or are having. Everyone's recovery is indeed different, and some will have a lot more pain and harder times than others, but I don't believe any story of no pain from day one, or totally recovered at a week, etc.
My choice is to be as deeply out as is safe for me, with zero chance of waking during the surgery. My husband had a cancerous mole surgically removed from his head a while back and had the choice of being totally out, or in some kind of light anesthesia where he might waken. He chose the light one and after the surgery the doctor came out and told me he was awake during most of the surgery and moving around a lot, plus talking non-stop....lol. They had to keep telling him to lie still and quit talking. No way I want to experience that with any surgery, and especially not one with drills, saws, hammers, chisels, etc, being used! I know doctors will say you won't remember a thing, but I tell them I don't want to hear or see anything I "won't remember".....lol. But for those who want that, I guess it's a good thing that they have the choice.