I am so glad you mentioned your two hips have complained very differently (one while walking, one while sitting)! Sometimes, I read pre-op posts on BoneSmart, and my private reaction to descriptions of activities so far beyond my ability is: “Is pain tolerance a superpower? ‘Cause I am pretty sure I don’t have it.”
So...now I understand why we don’t compare! Okay... I admit, I was a little slow on the uptake, but better late...Pre-op side, we’ve all got our own “special” blend of symptoms, with both commonality and variance.
And, I totally agree, it’s a moving target, day to day, to adapt to whatever new distress signal our compromised joint(s) sends. A good friend chastised me lovingly, a while back. She reminded me this hip has been a stalwart friend for lo these many years, and perhaps deserved a little gratitude and cooperation from me, instead of impatience and resentment. Which means, I think, I have to listen to the distress signals, offer comfort, and cooperate with the limits my old friend has these days.
So...that’s my philosophy meditation for today

.
As far as your reluctance to medicate, I certainly sympathize. I have a tried a few things for my hip pain, and the thing that works best is sleep. Next best is resting the hip. And then comes 8-hour extra strength Tylenol, which I take consistently to keep the drug at a therapeutic level. Good days, I wake up relaxed and comfortable. At some point during the day, I exceed my “pitch count”, and then the day is kaput. If I overdo, the pain wins, and a bad cycle of sleep deprivation and increased pain gets started. I don’t think I could sleep now without Tylenol, so it’s the lesser of two evils. (My primary and PT recommended I stop NSAIDs.)
My DD bought me a new swim ensemble (from Athleta): swim shorts and built-in bra tankini. The shorts will cover either incision (approach still undecided) without worries about elastic in a tender place. The tankini is au courant, and the built-in bra will be a confidence builder in public. It arrives today or tomorrow and then we’ll be off to see which of the local pools will be most helpful in terms of access and classes. Wish me luck!
It’s just one adaptation after another, isn’t it?