Please also understand that with every medication and every procedure there are documented benefits and risks. Something that works beautifully and easily for one person may be disastrous for the next. It's the documentation and each person weighing benefits and risks that is key. And we owe all our members the opportunity to understand this.
totally agree with this
I have been unable to find independent, unbiased, non industry funded studies on the effectiveness (and risks) of this procedure
I've got 3 friends who had it, and all 3 were happy with it, HOWEVER only one of them had a TKR without it, to be able to compare pain levels- and she was glad she had it done.
That said, oftentimes you can have both knees done and have very different experiences with them, even if the procedure and meds are identical (or as close as possible to identical) I've heard many say one was easier than the other
my other two friends were happy with the Iovera but they'd never had knee surgery before, so how do they know how much of an effect the Iovera had?
I was all set to get the Iovera til I heard from a nurse who participated in hundreds of TKRs and who said she did not see any huge benefit overall for most patients. I'm writing to ask her if she's got studies or numbers to back this up (she mentioned tracking certain outcomes for her surgeon who was interested in provided the best experience for his patients)
but I am going to decline the Iovera. Another thing that seems odd to me is that the office that does this procedure is unwilling to bill any insurance besides standard Medicare (they will not work with medicare advantage plans, medicaid nor ANY other type of insurance)
to me that says it's likely very difficult to get it approved, which doesn't necessarily mean it's not effective, but can mean that there is just not enough evidence to do a cost/benefit analysis , which seems likely considering how hard it is to find studies
it might be worth if it you can not get surgery, if you are too frail or have other barriers to surgery, it might be something you'd want to invest in.
But I found out about other things that can be done and other things that they are now doing in surgery to decrease post op pain, so I feel a lot better about going with what's covered now
I too am very happy for those who got good results with Iovera, and I hope they'll make it a covered benefit for those who have no other good options, if it proves to be worth the cost.