THR recommended...but not in pain

Status
Not open for further replies.
Hi Twistycap, my situation is like so many others, it gets bad quickly. It has been twenty years now from my first symptom, through the years my hip has gotten worse, but in the last year or so the deterioration has been rapid. I could walk for an hour or so and be sore later but usually was better in the morning. But now I rely on a crutch to get around, and can't stand without significant pain for more than 10 minutes. I was undecided when I first came across Bonesmart, I thought I wasn't bad enough, but I'm pleased that I have started the process (I'm waiting for a surgery date) because even in the last month, I've gotten a bit worse again. In the last week I've noticed pain on getting up out of my car after the half hour drive to work. If you will need to be on a waiting list, get on it sooner rather than later.

Good luck with making your decision, it's not an easy one.

Best wishes :flwrysmile:
 
Welcome to BoneSmart TC... ditto everything that has already been said..

But just to add.. if radiologically you are showing bone-on-bone, this is not going to improve.. the damage is there, time for a THR :)
 
Unfortunately my situation was a lot different than most people who need a THR. I had a broken hip unknowingly for a month before finding out it was so shattered that I had to have a replacement. I will say this though. I've heard you say that your limitations arent as bad as some of the limitations that others have experienced. What you need to remember is that every body is different, and the FACT is that YOU are having limitations that are not normal for you. Your hip is not going to get better on its own. And I can almost guarantee that those limitations and discomfort will be gone after recovery from surgery. Considering how active you are I would imagine recovery going quite well:) ultimately the decision is yours, but I would highly recommend surgery sooner rather than later.
 
TwistyCap,

I'm just a few years older than you and not nearly the shape you are in, but I have experienced the Payback Pain that you have experienced. A couple things I gleaned from your first post is that you are already bone on bone. Cartilage does not regenerate and although your pain may not be 'daily' the more you use your hip it will only continue to deteriorate. The other thing is that the payback pain and daily living limitations will also get worse over time. How much time? No one can say. I think you are already looking at THR, so the question becomes how much can you tolerate and for how long. Only you can make that decision but one thing that is possibly out of your control is what one thing will tip the scale. Problem is it could happen tomorrow. You need to have a good heart to heart with yoursellf, find an OS you can trust and have confidence in and see what their schedule is and how it coincides with your own. Good luck and keep us posted.
 
I am noticing something of a trend going on in these forums. In the two years since I first started reading these boards, we skewed toward people in their 50s and 60s. We had a sprinkling of 40 somethings, and an even tinier handful of "youngsters." At least that's how I remember it. But now it seems hardly a day goes by that we don't have a new poster in their mid-30s or 40s.

Our youngest posters....20- 30 somethings usually have had some kind of congenital issue or disease, or perhaps accidents that have created conditions where a THR is the optimal solution. The decision to go ahead is perhaps a bit easier...whatever the reasons, lives have been deeply affected. Pain is crippling. Plans for a future are on hold.

For us older folks, the decision is also easier. Often we have seen a gradual descent into a loss of mobility and accompanying pain. Our doctors may have told us earlier on that we should wait as long as possible, so our new hip would not wear out before we did. But here we are in the magic age range....old enough to probably need only one go-round, and young enough to withstand the rigors of surgery. It's really a no-brainer, although many of us in our 60s realize after-the-fact that we wish we'd done it sooner. Sometimes you don't realize how much you've lost until you get it back.

But for a variety of reasons, there is a larger population in their 40s now who are finding out that they have serious hip degeneration. This is occurring at a time when medical technology has turned THRs into an assembly line procedure. It's still major surgery, but the complication risks are pretty small, and the end results are usually pretty terrific. It's also a time when the results have a pretty good chance of lasting a lifetime, so the earlier arguments for waiting are no longer valid.

Twistycap, as you can see from other posters, you are indicative of a growing group of hip patients trying to make decisions about a condition that is not life-threatening, and has not yet become debilitating. The key question for each individual is how much is too much? How much limping is acceptable? Knitter4444 said it...limping is not normal. It is a sign that there is a problem. It's a problem that only gets worse. How much soreness is acceptable? How many activities that have to be modified, or given up entirely, is acceptable? Crippling pain makes it easy to decide, but when the pain is tolerable enough that we can still bumble around, we tend to put up with it.

But here's the thing. We seem to want to justify our decision to get the THR. Oh the pain was unbearable....I got to where I couldn't stand in line at a movie without pain....I couldn't get on the floor to play with my kids/grandkids...these are valid justifications. Here's another very valid justification....I could see the handwriting on the wall and I wanted to get it done while I still had good health otherwise. Or...I am in the peak of my life and I want to maintain that for as long as possible.

TC, take all the time you need to make this decision. Eventually, you'll know what to do. Something will change, or your thinking will change, and you'll know you're ready. The surgical assembly line will be ready whenever you are. If you live in an area where waiting lists are long and can take many months, it doesn't hurt to get on a waiting list. It also doesn't hurt to cancel....someone out there is wishing for a spot to open up due to a cancellation. You just keep your options open until it's clear what you need to do, and when you need to do it.

Sharon
 
For me, I limped for years and I have back pain too. A couple of years ago, I had a strange new pain in my groin. After an MRI, I was told I had arthritis. The pain was managable for those first two years but definitely hampered my activities. Early this year, the pain level in my hip went to a new level. My limp made me look like the hunchback of notre dame. I couldn't reach my right foot, couldn't shave my right leg etc. After an April vacation with friends, they convinced me to go to an ortho. Xray revealed bone on bone. It seemed to progress so fast. Dr daid it was likely I had a small piece of cartlidge in there and if finally gave way which put me at bone on bone. I questioned if I was ready for months, but as the year wore on, the pain got increasingly worse and my range of motion decreased. I stopped going places that required me to walk long distances. I turned into a grumpy limpy unhappy and yes scared, person. When my date finally got here, I was SO ready! If I knew then what I know now, I probably would have done this earlier in the year and got about the process of recovery sooner. I freaked myself out worried that I would be immobile for months, never be able to do certain things, etc. I researched for months, watched surgeries, talked to everyone I could who had done this. My reality is that my recovery was remarkably smooth and I have better range of motion with no pain than before surgery. This is your journey so you have to make your own path. This is the right place to browse and ask questions. Read some of the posts and follow some of the recoveries, you will find similiarities in some of the cases. I can tell you in my case I spent more months than I should have in pain because once the bone on bone pain hit, holy smoke did it hurt! That said, I am glad I had a Halloween surgery because I was ready both physically and mentally. Good luck in your decision!
 
Actually, Octopus suggested the waiting list first. I just piggybacked on it to make sure it wouldn't get lost in the pile of responses. :) So...octopus Great suggestion about the waiting list!
 
I'm was in a similar situation just a couple of months ago. Told I was bone on bone and needed a THR and totally freaked out. I wasnt in that much pain at the time and didnt think I was that bad, but I was starting to have problems that I too made light of. Went into total denial and virtually told the OS he was a fool and didnt know what he was talking about, that he must have mixed my MRI scans/x rays with someone else, that I was very active and did loads and loads of exercise (I didnt mention the payback pain I was getting) Told him that I didnt need a THR, I didnt want a THR, and I wasnt having a THR thank you very much. Boy do I regret it. My hip is going downhill very very quickly and the pain is getting worse daily. Ive come out of denial and realise I need and I WANT it done now, but now Ive got to go back to my GP , get re-referred back to the OS etc and go through the whole process again , whereas I could be sitting pretty on the waititng list now with surgery scheduled in the near future.
I agree with everything thats been said. Its not going to get better, only worse, and the common theme Ive read on here is when your hip decides to deteriorate, it does so very quickly. Get on the waititng list sooner rather than later. I wish I had.
 
Hello TeeEm, welcome to your international BoneSmart family, great that you have joined.

Yes TeeEm, when hips demonstrate radiologically that a THR is required however, there is not much associated pain to start with, I have often noted on the forum that the hip deteriorates quite rapidly and symptoms become apparent..

Being in Australia, I am unfamiliar with your NHS system, but I have read that the waiting lists can be long however, take heart because cancellations are quite common, so keep contacting them to remind them.. that has often worked for some UK members.

Would you like to start your own thread in the hip pre op area. You will find a black tab at the top right hand side displaying ‘Post New Thread’. Click on that and decide on the title you want for your thread, then start writing and share a little about your story that has lead you to a THR.

The benefit of having your own thread is that you can ask more specific questions relating to your personal situation and we can answer them. Also other members will pop by and respond to you directly with their experiences and support.

Looking forward to your first post in your own thread, then I can give you some links to our extensive list of articles which may answer some of your concerns, knowledge is power... but fire away with any questions, we love questions.

Here is a particular favorite of mine to get you started.

Five “P’s” of hip recovery

Once again, welcome, we are here to support and encourage you!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Staff online

Members online

Back
Top Bottom