@KHill I used some of the research tools we have in our Library to look up knitquilt's suggested surgeon. He has some good numbers and seems highly recommended by his patients. Here's the links to those sites.
https://www.checkbook.org/surgeonratings/ is done by a not-for-profit consumer organization. Doesn't cover all types of surgeries, just mostly high risk procedures. (a plastic surgeon I saw for a hand issue is not listed, for instance).
https://projects.propublica.org/surgeons/ ProPublica is a nonprofit journalism organization. This covers 8 elective procedures (including Hip and Knee) and surgeon scorecards based on complications encountered. Downside is that they only track Medicare patients, so a large segment of patients with other insurance aren't included. Has a lot of search and graph options, including by hospital in a particular state.
https://projects.propublica.org/docdollars/ See which doctors took money (and how much) from drug and device makers. Only through 2015, though. Not always a bad thing, as some surgeons may be receiving payments when they have invented or helped develop a new medical device.