@Summeryy .....skating and skiing share so many of the same movements. Yes the recovery does take more time than either of us would like.
@Flashlight .... that makes sense. My damage was largely lateral due to an old injury, so I had a valgus deformity which is rarer than the more common varus. So my leg got corrected out.
I think some of the assumption is that the majority of pain comes from swelling and stiffness.... which may be true. This is the pain I and I'm sure many of you are accustomed to. For years a typical ski day always ends with limping and ice maybe some anti-inflammatory and then doing it all again the next day. However this is not the only source of pain.
Muscle imbalance also causes the body to compensate in ways that cause stress and pain. As my knee degenerated I started having more back issues.... piriformis issues... etc.. I started compensating and using my weak leg less. My quad atrophied ... the HA injections no longer helped. My knee lost range of motion. I was not however in daily knee pain. I was somehow compensating too well. But the growing disfunction of the leg became untenable. I did not have a replacement to stop pain.... but I did do it to restore function. PT alone wasn't doing the job anymore, my knee was continuing to deteriorate and my body alignment was going with it.
I can rest and let the swelling subside and I will be more comfortable. With gentle exercise and movement (motion is lotion) my body will heal. I don't disagree with that concept...for many it's the right thing to do. I crave more..... even if it means a little more discomfort for now. I think the important thing is if I'm going to do more aggressive PT I have to do it right. I have a therapist that watches my every move and immediately corrects me if I try and compensate in any way. If something hurts (which is different from fatigue) we either make a correction or stop doing it. I think people get in trouble because they don't listen to their body and do the moves incorrectly and/or too much which leads to all kinds of problems. I'm trying to be deliberate and focused which is very hard for my ADHD self to do. The new knee needs as much balance and support from the surrounding tissues as the old knee in order to function well. So I've decided to focus on that. Mark my words.... I will be skiing before this season ends. It's the golden ring that keeps me moving forward. I'm already bummed watching the snow beginning to fly and watching posts from my friends making their first turns of the season.