I'm also in the function over fashion camp. My go-to "boot" has been a hiker from Cabela's/Bass Pro. It is their "Redhead" brand. It took a couple of walks to "break in" but not too uncomfortable in the process, just stiff. Once done I was even able to wear them my entire 12 hour shift on my feet when I forgot to bring my work shoes. These are very affordable and I think much more comfortable than the double priced Columbia hikers I bought, although you'll want to waterproof them for better winter weather conditions coverage. I wish I had just stuck with my tried and true but a gift card has a way of talking you out of common sense sometimes. Lol. This will be a fun thread to follow.