Guest viewing is limited

NY Times article on Knee Strengthening

Makes me very happy I've been working like crazy on my quads!

Thanks for posting this Gretchendz.

Mag
 
200 subjects is a very small study and I have read the opposite point of view.
 
Josephine;

I did not understand your reply about Quad strengthening? Even without this article it is very important to rebuild your muscles and with the quads being the largest and most influential to the proper workings of a knee I don't understand your objections. i have never read where not building your muscles back is beneficial??

I am 11 weeks out from BI-TKR and the more exercises I do primarily leg work the better I am. 0% extension 130+ Flexion on both.

Max
 
I didn't object - I just pointed out that 200 subjects is a very small sample, which it is for true empirical research. 2,000 would have given more informative data.

As for the second part, I meant that much research I have seen (but don't have access to now) has not observed any significant differences in
long term results between those who did do pre-op exercises and those who did not. Which is not to say it's not a good thing to do it! Any and all exercise is good!
 
I liked the idea of faster recovery time if I do lunges and squats and leg press before TKR. and with PT after surgery it's even better.

there's no such thing as too much exercise if the motive was to have quicker healing and recovery. :)
 
Totally 100% agree. You're quads not only are important for your structural integrity they are also important for your cardio fitness. Being the largest muscles in your body they require more oxygen while exercising and deliver the best cardio benefit.

The bummer was for me that my leg was so crooked that I couldn't build quad strength and my right leg muscle is about 50% less than the left....
 
Bummer for me at the moment is that my broken toe has become sore again so I cannot wear shoes to go on my bike! I'm now going to try in bare feet! GOT to get those muscles pumped somehow! And my knee is getting stiff ...
 
What a surprise! It was actually easier with just socks on! Well, I drive in bare feet so what's the diff?
 
Good on you Jo, I have ridden my bike all this time in bare feet. Probably if I was cycling for 30 mins or more I'd need shoes, but I get too bored to go for 30 mins anyway.

It's hard to know if pre op exercise would have helped me or not, I was almost totally immobile prior to my op, and now at 12 weeks (tomorrow) after, I feel amazing I am doing so much, swimming, walking, cycling, when I go to a shop or an appointment I can park where I choose and walk to it rather than circle the block to find a park out the front. Even Post Op my physio was nothing, I hear stories or 2 1/2 hours with the PT,excrutiating pain and tears. I had at the very most 30 mins, 1 day a week for 3 weeks, then was discharged from physio. Not once did I get to a point it was painful, and I have just plodded on at home myself since.

So to do or not to do pre op can be relative to the person, some people can't exercise prior to the op. (Broken toes don't help either).

Chris :)
 
Actually, I think this study is POST-op if you read it carefully.

Anyway, I'm with you Jo--the more exercise you can do the better.
 
I have run, walked, biked and lifted for years and years and even with limitations this last year becauer of my bad knee I managed to keep some muscle strength in the quads and hip flexors. Before my TKR 3 weeks ago I spent a few months doing extra isometric quad sets because they were the only thing that seemed to work even a little. It all paid off after the operation and now - even at just 3 weeks and with my surgeon limiting how much resistance I can use on my new knee until 6 weeks -- I can see my quads beginning -- just beginning to rebuild. Muscles have memory (works really well for marathon runners) and my muscles, weakened as they were, are now remembering. ANd strengthening faster than if I had never done anything. Plus I have a very good PT who keeps challenging me within the surgeon's limits. Nothing beats exercise properly done. ANd just walking as much as possible rebuilds all those muscles too. Funny they always have to do a study to prove the obvious.
And Jo -- I too have done my exercise bike at home in bare feet, slippers, flip flops -- whatever -- at least for short runs and without a lot of resistance. Plus you know you can take an old pair of sneakers or running shoes and cut out a place for your sore toe. I recall having to do that when I broke my little toe by hitting it on a doorway - klutz that I am. It took forever it seemed to heal.
 
Now that's a good idea! But sadly I don't have any sneakers. Guess bare feet and socks will have to do! You have motivated me to get working on the old bike, however. Glad I did that time in the gym last year.
 
Back
Top Bottom