Guest viewing is limited

Am I a Loser???

Status
Not open for further replies.

Fawnde

new member
Joined
Jan 29, 2009
Messages
1
Location
United States
I'm new to this forum and have found a LOT of great information here, but I still have a few questions. I had a TKR on Dec 8th and my PT has been minimal due to lack of personel, the holidays, miscommunication,etc. My OS is recommending a manipulation since my flexion is only 75 (my extension is -1, which I'm told is good). My OS is trying to make me feel like a total loser because I didn't reach 90 by two weeks after surgery and after 7 weeks I STILL didn't make it. He's making it this Manipulation sound like the losers way out and it's gonna be so painful. At this point, I expect a good bit of pain , but I want to make sure that I have the supporting PT to help me. I also feel that with the proper PT after the first surgery, I wouldn't be in the situation. Any thoughts????
 
What a load of .... no way are you a loser! Adhesions happen and so does needing a manipulation. Lots of people have to have them. Sometimes it can be avoided by aggressing therapy but often as not, it's not your fault. So let me first put your mind at rest - this is quite probably nothing to do with not having done enough PT or been 'good enough' in what you did.

Here is my standard mini-lecture on the subject so read and absorb ...

All the structures in the body, muscles, tendons, ligaments, even gut and lungs, need to be able to glide over one another smoothly to let our bodies work. To do this, the body produces a special viscous fluid that acts like the oil in your car engine and lubricates everything with great efficiency.

Now when the surgeon opens up any part of our body, the internal stuff gets exposed to the air which is, by comparison to the inside of the body, cool and dry. The natural reaction is that fluids evaporate and tissues cool. This makes the organs and structures dry so when the wound is closed, part of the healing process is for the body to go into overdrive, producing extra fluid to replace what is lost. This is one reason why you need IV fluids during and after an operation.

Now as a general rule, 95% of people manage to make up this fluid loss and normality is restored quite quickly. But in the other 5%, for a variety of reasons some known, most unknown, their bodies are deficient in making up this loss and lacking the necessary lubrication, the ligaments and muscles lose their 'glide-ability' and begin to stick or adhere to one another. This is why they are often refered to as 'adhesions'.

NB: Some people (and surgeons!) often refer to this as scar tissue which is a bit of a misnomer. Scar tissue is abnormal or fibrous tissue that's grown in a place as a result of trauma like an incision. Adhesions are just normal tissues stuck together.

Anyway, if this occurs and the function of the joint is affected, the answer is to work the joint with some force, thereby freeing the structures from their locked-in state. Much as you would if you got a sticky or rusty lock and put some oil in it, you'd work it back and forth to free it up. That's all a manipulation is.

Get it done and move on. Never mind what he sayd about it! But yes, you do need a really good PT to see you through afterwards. Two or three members here have had MUAs and done really well after.
 
Fawnde Welcome to bone smart.

You are certainly not a loser. I hope your surgeon was just having a bad day and really does not treat you like that.
Of course Jo gave you a wonderful explanation. There are a lot of parts of my body I just can not seem to whip into shape, certainly I do not feel like a loser, nor should you.

It will work, I have read of many who had manipulations and are happpy with thedir progress after, get yourself a good pt and you will be fine. Post often and you will feel and do better.
Judy
 
Welcome Fawnde! Jo and Sewell are absolutely right! You can't be a loser....you were strong enough to get the surgery in the first place and you've worked as best you could given the PT scheduling problems.

When you see your surgeon, tell him how his comments made you feel. These guys sometimes need some "tough love" feedback and he probably was not aware of the impact his remarks had.

Keep focused on the goal....it is to get your mobility and your life back. Whatever it takes is what you should do. Numbers (ROM) are a good guide, but the REAL issue is how you are able to function in your life. The manipulations seem to work very well to loosen things up. Go for it!! You'll have support here!
 
Welcome. Of course I concur with Jo and all my compadres here on our forum. Also, you know your own body better than anybody. You have done your best, and an MUA is not a value judgment--or certainly shouldn't be. Most here who have had one have described it in positive terms.
 
Fawnde, I have to agree with what the others are telling you. Oh, and welcome to Bonesmart, you came to the best place you could possibly come for advice, encouragment and information in general. The people here are kind and caring and Jo is a wonder, a nurse who has dedicated her life to helping others and a knee replacement candidate to boot. Whatever advice she gives you you can take to the bank. I had BTKR in May and have adhesions in my right knee, although it has not affected my ROM or my extention, I am fortunate in that regard. Any OS who uses the Nazi techniques that your OS is using needs to have some adhesions of his own, preferably from having a size 12 boot removed from his backside. Many people on this forum have had to have a manipulation and you are the first who I have heard whose OS has tried to make it sound like it was your fault. This surgery is a difficult one and has a long recovery timeframe. Like you I had difficulty getting my PT scheduled and ended up only going 3 times total. Fortunately for me I had PT after a couple of knee scopes and knew what I needed to do and did it on my own so when I was about six weeks post op and went to my OS for my final exam he saw how well I had done thus far on my own and said I wouldn't need further PT. Maybe you would have done better if you had had more PT, there is just no way of knowing but I would bet that what Jo has said is right and that regardless of the amount of PT you had or how hard you worked you would still need a manipulation. Go back and look at the posts from the last year and you will find several people who worked there buns off in PT and still needed manipulations. I hope that what everyone is telling you makes you feel better and relieves your guilt as you have nothing to feel guilty about. If anyone should feel guilty it is your OS for using such shameful tactics. Good luck. I will keep an eye out for your posts. Rowdy
 
Fawnde,
I can honestly say that you are Not A Loser!!! Hey I should
know I am the President of the Loser's Club and your name is not
on the Member's List. I may have noticed your Doctor's name.

No, just listen to all the good folks here. They will tell you the
Gods truth. I have read about a lot of people getting Manipulations
and they seem to think it was a good thing. You just have to trust
you gut feeling. And Jo will help you there.
^i^
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom